When I decided to take my fishing hobby to the next level, my decision came down between a fishing kayak and an inflatable pontoon. I knew I was in for a big decision, so I sat down for a few hours and done tons of research to ensure I chose the right option for me. One of the greatest joys in life is fishing, no doubt. Fishing off of the bank of the lake can satisfy those who are looking for the bare bones experience, however for those who seek ultimate fulfillment or trophy bass usually find themselves on the water in some form at some point. I have compiled a detailed source of all the information I learned when I did my research in hopes that you can choose what’s best for you.
When it came down to the fishing kayak or the inflatable pontoon, I sat down for a couple of hours and did some research. Ultimately, I chose the fishing kayak for its durability, versatility, and overall popularity. However, the inflatable pontoon makes a strong case on why it is to be chosen over the fishing kayak. Inflatable pontoons are cheap, easy to store, and easy to transport. It all comes down to personal preference and to help you make that decision, I have compiled a complete comparison in this article.
Price
The biggest question most anglers have when it comes time to dive on in. For me, deciding to part with the cash is the hard part as I am very frugal. The inflatable pontoon takes home the gold in the price category for being so cheap that I had to triple-check the price tag.
I was astounded when researching the going price for inflatable pontoons, even the top models were moderately priced below a thousand dollars. Entry-level models, which I do not recommend for the simple fact that you get what you pay for, are priced around two hundred dollars. The price of the inflatable pontoon makes it deserving of consideration for the budget fisherman looking to take his fishing game to the next level.
For the fishing kayak, the price is not as pleasing. Your bottom line fishing kayaks start around three hundred dollars with the top models pushing anywhere between a thousand to three thousand. That alone is enough to turn off most fishermen, especially if you’re unsure about the hobby as a whole. That being said, many kayak dealers will hold ‘demo days’ allowing curious fisherman to try out dozens of different types of kayaks to assist in choosing the right one for you.
Also, I would like to note that at the time of writing this article I have owned my kayak for six years. I paid around 1200 dollars for mine and have gotten enough use and enjoyment out of it to justify spending that much money, but that’s just me.
Transportation
How to get from home to the fishing hole is important. Having a truck or a tow worthy vehicle is almost necessary, but luckily the inflatable pontoon packs down into a duffel bag. If you enjoy the ease of transport then the inflatable pontoon is just what you’re looking for.
With as popular as SUV’s are in today’s world, it is no surprise that many are lacking a truck bed to haul things in. Where the inflatable pontoon really shines is its ability to compact down into a duffel bag and fit into nearly any vehicle space. Cars, vans, maybe even a motorcycle if you’re creative and daring enough, can haul the pontoon no problem. Many professional fishermen choose an inflatable pontoon for its ability to be taken on an airplane as well.
In terms of transportation, kayaks are kind of cut and dry. Throw your kayak into a truck bed or trailer and then secure it. After about 10 minutes, you’re back on the road. The only advantage the fishing kayak has in this regard is its simplicity and the time it takes to load it up. The kayak is as it is, meaning you don’t have to sit and wait for it to deflate and then try to stuff it into a bag, you just load it up.
Alternatively, you can just load us inflatable pontoons on a trailer just as I have in this picture.
Ease of Use
Simplicity is something to be appreciated, that’s why I value the ability of my kayak to just be pulled out of my truck bed and pushed into the water. Not ten minutes after I arrive at the lake/river I’m off and onto fishing, and that is what makes the fishing kayak easier to use than the inflatable pontoon.
The kayak is heavier and a bit more bulky but that’s livable considering the time it takes to get going. The only way the kayak can possibly fall short in this category is the fact that some kayakers prefer a buddy to help them load and unload their kayak, but this can be worked around. Several companies produce pull systems that make loading a fully loaded kayak a breeze, you could also opt for a trailer if you want something easier or do not have the luxury of a truck bed.
Sitting on the river bank waiting for my boat to blow up just doesn’t seem appealing at all. The pump will either need power from an outlet or a couple of batteries, in which you better have a backup. You want to be sure that your boat is inflating evenly, leaving no creases which can build up the pressure and strain the material. After a long day of fishing the inflatable must be deflated properly using the pump and returned to the storage back, make sure that there is no water left on the pontoon or inside the storage bag as this can cause problems with care later down the road. It is okay, however, to throw your inflatable pontoon in the bag and then air it out properly after returning home. However, you choose to do it will still more than likely be a pain. Many fishermen opt to blow up the inflatable pontoon before leaving the house and haul it in the bed of a pickup or in a trailer, which works but defeats the purpose of owning one for its ease of transport.
Maneuverability/Versatility
Deciding to take to the water means that you want to access parts of the water that are unreachable by fishing on the bank. Why would you wish to hinder your ability to move throughout the water as you please when that was your entire goal, to begin with? That’s where the fishing kayak barely comes out ahead in this category.
The fishing kayak comes in all shapes and sizes, each with different perks and drawbacks. When it comes down to fit into the most narrow of gaps, the fishing kayak is the go to. If your secret fishing hole or preferred deep spot requires a slip in between debris such as rocks or fallen trees, fishing kayaks are slim and more forgiving should you bump your boat on the way in. They are also far easier to reach into the water with should you need your hands at the side of your kayak to pick something up.
The inflatable pontoon appears to be clunky and hard to maneuver, however they are more graceful than they appear to be. Boasting the same turning capabilities of the much more expensive kayak, they make a very strong case. However, they lack the ability to squeeze into smaller places that a kayak would have no problem with. The inflatable pontoon also has trouble with its bulkiness, making it hard to reach over the side of the boat into the water should you need to do so.
Durability
When I’m ready to purchase something, one of the first questions that come to my mind is: How much of a beating can this take? I’m not neglectful of my equipment but I like knowing that if it came down to it, it could handle whatever may be thrown at it. As in terms of durability, the fishing kayak takes the cake here.
Modern kayaks are made from rotomolded polyethylene, which is a form of tough, soft, and flexible plastic. I have seen many of kayaks, including my own take numerous beatings and still stand the test of time. That’s not to say that these fishing vessels are indestructible, however. Nothing will ruin a kayak faster than improper storage in the heat, dragging it down a shallow river, or striking something significant on the seam.
Inflatable pontoons are surprisingly quite durable in their own right. The truth is, durability often lies in the price point of the inflatable, that being said you cannot realistically expect the same quality as a kayak which is made from solid materials. Inflatable pontoons are made of canvas and appear to be very fragile at first glance, but I was pleasantly surprised to learn that they can take considerable amounts of abuse also. It is important to remember that they are just canvas and should be properly stored themselves, and maintained well. Watching out for anything that can puncture your inflatable should a concern as well.
Storage/Care
The most important part of owning a water vessel is proper storage and care. Rather you own a small yacht or just a pool float, without proper care, your ride will deteriorate and eventually leave you with some major problems. As far as ease of storage and care goes, I would have to pick the inflatable pontoon over the fishing kayak.
With the inflatable pontoon being, well inflatable, that makes it super convenient to deflate and store nearly anywhere. This is a key takeaway for someone with little to no storage space. Most of your inflatables come with a storage bag, so folding it up should be no more difficult than an air mattress. The only thing you should be aware of here is to make sure there is NO water on the boat or in the bag when storing it, also be sure to store in a dry place that is room temperature. When it comes time to wash your inflatable pontoon, you can use environmentally friendly, non-abrasive chemicals to do the job. Proper storage of your inflatable pontoon will help it last for a handful of years.
The kayak falls short yet again (unless you have plenty of storage space). Fishing kayaks are several feet long and also generally heavy. You cannot deflate them and they take up a lot of space. Your best option is to hang them on the wall of a basement or shed using specially made mounts. The good thing is that if they are properly stored, the heat does not bother them. When it comes to cleaning your kayak it is done much the same way, with eco-friendly non-abrasive cleaning agents. The biggest advantage over the inflatable pontoon is that they last a lot longer when properly cared for and are not as prone to holes when maintained.
Community
The community aspect of fishing, to some, is what makes it great. However, fishing is great because of the ability to go solo or involve your entire family. If you enjoy the community around specific hobbies then a fishing kayak is the right choice for you.
When it comes to the community of kayak fishing, the possibilities are endless. Local and national kayak fishing groups host a wide variety of fishing tournaments with all kinds of stipulations. The rules can be serious or even whacky but one thing is for sure, you are bound to have fun. The community of kayak fishing doesn’t stop at tournaments, there are all kinds of group events and get-togethers for even the most modest of fisherman. When it comes to enjoying everything and everyone involved in a hobby, kayak fishing is the ultimate experience!
A community is something lacking from the inflatable pontoon experience. If you don’t want to bother with fishing tournaments or group festivities aren’t your thing, then the inflatable pontoon is still a solid choice.
Final Thoughts
The inflatable pontoon is better suited to the budget fisherman while the kayak is geared to more hardcore fisherman. Each boat has its pros and cons associated with them and it’s up to you to choose which one works for you. The key takeaway from this article is to not miss out on a great opportunity. If you are interested in taking to the water to do some fishing, get something. Regardless of what you choose to take you out onto the water, you will have fun and you will get your money’s worth. Kayak fishing has changed my life and my favorite hobby, fishing, for the better. Do not be afraid to get out on the water and try something new.
